Grill Outlet > Brands > Weber > Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 18 vs 22 (Review)

Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 18 vs 22 (Review)

Weber has a nearly cult following by grilling fanatics, due to its innovative designs, reliability, and high-quality performance. It isn’t unusual to see a Weber grill at BBQ competitions, and Weber’s line of Smokey Mountain Cookers can compete with commercial-grade smokers in the quality of tender, fall off the bone meat that is produced. Trying to decide between the Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 18 vs 22? Read these Weber Smokey Mountain reviews to help you make up your mind.

Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 18 vs 22

The Weber Smokey Mountain 18 and Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 22 are both excellent smokers by Weber.

Both have similar features like a built in lid thermometer, a door for adding coal, water, or wood chips, and a sturdy, low-impact design that won’t dominate your patio.

Weber 18-inch Smokey Mountain Cooker
$329.00
$399.99
in stock
4 new from $329.00
3 used from $296.63
as of January 23, 2021 5:26 am
Amazon.com
Weber 22-inch Smokey Mountain Cooker
$439.00
in stock
9 new from $439.00
1 used from $403.88
as of January 23, 2021 5:26 am
Amazon.com

The primary difference between these two models is, of course, in the size. The Weber Smokey Mountain 18 has 481 square inches of cooking area, as opposed to 726 square inches on the WSM 22. The 18” has plenty of room for a family BBQ but if you want to cook for the whole neighborhood, the 22” might be your best bet.

There is another important difference between these two smokers, aside from size. The Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 22 tends to cook hotter than the WSM 18. It is difficult to keep temps below 275 on the larger model, so if you like to cook long, low, and slow, the 18 may be your better choice.

If, however, you tend to cook large slabs of meat that can tolerate higher temperatures and need more room, the WSM 22 might be the one for you. A huge water pan lets you add enough moisture to keep meat succulent, even when cooked at higher temperatures.

Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 18

The Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 18 is the classic Weber Smokey. This midsize WSM has enough room to cook plenty of food to feed the average family for a few days, and it cooks at low, consistent temperatures that produce meat on par with food made in commercial smokers.

Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker
Weber 18-inch Smokey Mountain Cooker

Pros

● Mid-sized smoker won’t take up too much room on your patio
● Plenty of cooking area for the average family
● Produces commercial smoker results at a reasonable price
● Portable enough to go to BBQ competitions with you
● Cooks at a very low, consistent temperature

Cons

● Ineffective lid temperature gauge
● Ill fitted door lets in oxygen and lets out smoke unless you adjust it carefully
● Not big enough for a full rack of ribs without scorching edges

Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 18 Review

The Weber Smokey Mountain 18 is the medium-sized unit in the Weber Smokey series. A cooking surface of 481 square inches is big enough for the average family to smoke whatever they want to eat–for several days. This little smoker can compete with the big commercial cookers at BBQ competitions. Don’t think that you have to go big to take your BBQ seriously. This little charcoal smoker packs some punch.

If you want to be able to grill a full rack of ribs evenly, you may want to go up a size, since this Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker doesn’t have a room without letting the edges of the ribs get scorched. This size, on the other hand, does a great job of maintaining low temperatures, so if super slow low cooking is your style, this might be the pick for you.

Even a novice can produce excellent food on this easy to use smoker, but experts have found all kinds of tricks to make the best-smoked food you can find using this affordable and convenient smoker.

Like the other Weber Smokey Mountain Smokers, this model has a lid thermometer. While this thermometer may give you a sense of what is going on under the lid, it isn’t really accurate enough for producing the best possible food. Weber hasn’t improved their built-in thermometer, but they did add a soft grommet so that you can put your own digital thermometer in.

There is a small side door on the WSM 18 so that you can add water, coal, and wood as needed to achieve the desired cooling effect. On the 18” the door is a bit small and badly fit, so it has a tendency to let out your precious smoke and let in oxygen that causes flare-ups and makes it hard to kill the coals. While you can bend the door to create a better fit, keep in mind that if you add a lot during your smoking, this might be frustrating for you.

Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 22

Do you really like smoked meat? Make as much of it as you like in a sitting with the large surface area of the Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 22.

Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 22
Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 22

This big smoker cannot only fit a rack of ribs but can even fit a couple. Because of the bullet shape, it doesn’t take up too much more room on your patio than the 18” size. This charcoal smoker tends to cook a little hotter than the other Weber Smokey Mountain Cookers, so if low and slow is important to you, the 18” might be a better pick for you.

Pros

● Large smoker with plenty of room for several racks of ribs
● Won’t take up your whole patio, despite the large cooking area
● Huge water pan for moist meat
● Consistent temperatures for reliable results

Cons

● Tends to cook hot, and takes some tricks to get the temperature to stay down
● A huge water pan is difficult to clean and can’t be lined with standard tinfoil
● Ill fitted door and ineffective thermometer

Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 22 Review

If you take your grilling and smoking seriously and want to feed the whole neighborhood, not just your family, the Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 22 may be the choice for you. Because of the tall, bullet-shaped design, this smoker won’t take up much more room on your porch or patio than the smaller Weber Smokey Mountain Smokers.

A huge cooking surface of 22.5” is plenty of room for a full rack of ribs or the biggest roast you can find. Plenty of room on the cooking surface means that you won’t have to worry about the edges of your meat cooking differently than the rest. An incredibly stable temperature is maintained across the cooking surface.

It is easy to adjust the temperature by simply closing and opening the vents. That said, this smoker tends to run hotter than the Weber Smokey Mountain 18. It is difficult to get it to run below 275 degrees, so if long slow cooks are your thing, you might be frustrated by this big smoker.

If you mostly want to smoke large hunks of meat that can handle higher temperatures, this may still be a better pick for you than the smaller model, since there are tricks you can employ to get the temperature down when you need to.

The Smokey Mountain 22 has the same inaccurate lid thermometer and leaky side door of the 18”. The door is a little easier to handle since it is bigger, and there is a grommet for adding your own thermometer to overcome the thermometer issue.

The WSM 22 has a huge water pan with a large surface area that delivers plenty of water to moisten your meat. This pan is so large you won’t be able to easily wash it in your sink, and it is too big for even the largest size of tinfoil, so cleanup can be a bit frustrating.

We hope our Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 18 vs 22 comparison and reviews helped you in making a more informed decision. If you would like to see electric options, please visit our Masterbuilt Electric Smoker 30 vs 40 page.

 

Weber 18-inch Smokey Mountain Cooker

$399.99
$329.00
 in stock
4 new from $329.00
3 used from $296.63
Free shipping
Amazon.com
as of January 23, 2021 5:26 am

Features

  • Material Type: Steel
  • The Weber Smokey Mountain charcoal smoker helps you achieve an authentic smokehouse flavor at home
  • It can accommodate a whole turkey and an entire ham at the same time. Item weight- 39.1 pounds
  • Made of porcelain-enameled steel, this smoker comes with 2 nickel-plated 18-1/2-inch-wide cooking grates
  • Includes a water pan, thermometer, individual vents on bowl and lid, and heat-resistant nylon handle

Weber 22-inch Smokey Mountain Cooker

$439.00  in stock
9 new from $439.00
1 used from $403.88
Free shipping
Amazon.com
as of January 23, 2021 5:26 am

Features

  • Your purchase includes: One Weber 22-inch Smokey Mountain Cooker, Charcoal Smoker + Cover
  • Item overall dimensions: 23" W x 24" D x 48.5" H. Item weight: 68 lbs
  • Cooking Grid Dimensions 21 1/2 X 21 1/2". Main Grilling Area 363 Sq. Inches. Total Grilling Area 726 Sq. Inches
  • Easy assembly required, instructions avaialable in User Guide attachment.
  • Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker reaches approximadetely 190°F inside temperature

Leave a Comment